The Everton Forum • Re: Jordan Pickford
No point in treading over old ground, especially as it is generational and tied so much to emotion.
But i firmly believe if you put up a highlights reel of the best saves by Everton keepers, there wouldn't be much difference between those of Pickfords and those of Southalls.
I think Pickford is *as good* as Southall.
Trophy's are too disputable a source to use as the reason one is better.
BUT, the reason i would pick Southall as the better keeper (after a lot of thinking) is that the lowlights reel of the pair of them would dramatically skew against Pickford. There were a few years there where we saw quite a few clangers from Pickford
But i firmly believe if you put up a highlights reel of the best saves by Everton keepers, there wouldn't be much difference between those of Pickfords and those of Southalls.
I think Pickford is *as good* as Southall.
Trophy's are too disputable a source to use as the reason one is better.
BUT, the reason i would pick Southall as the better keeper (after a lot of thinking) is that the lowlights reel of the pair of them would dramatically skew against Pickford. There were a few years there where we saw quite a few clangers from Pickford
Statistics: Posted by superpull — Thu Mar 05, 2026 12:12 pm