Results from Phillies Nation’s Stay or Go series
Here is a look at the results from Phillies Nation’s Stay or Go series.
If you missed any of the 11 editions of Stay or Go, you can catch up using the links down below:
- Harrison Bader
- J.T. Realmuto
- Max Kepler
- Kyle Schwarber
- Ranger Suárez
- Nick Castellanos
- Orion Kerkering
- Taijuan Walker
- Alec Bohm
- Bryson Stott
- Brandon Marsh
Who led the way in Stay votes?
A whopping 91% of Phillies Nation readers want the Phillies to bring back J.T. Realmuto. Phillies fans were clamoring for the team to re-sign him when he was a free agent after the 2020 season. Five years later, the sentiment is still there.
Who led the way in Go votes?
Phillies fans and the Phillies front office are in agreement: Nick Castellanos should go. The right fielder received the highest percentage of go votes among the 11 players featured in the poll at 83%. Castellanos has one year left on his contract and it sounds like he’ll be playing for another team next season.
Biggest surprise?
What a gift. Harrison Bader performed better in voting than Kyle Schwarber. Bader received 89% of the stay votes in his individual poll compared to Schwarber’s 82%. Bryson Stott (84% stay) also performed better than Schwarber.
Full Results
We’ve received more than 24,000 votes across all 11 Stay or Go polls. Here are the full results:
- J.T. Realmuto — 91% Stay, 9% Go
- Harrison Bader — 89% Stay, 11% Go
- Bryson Stott — 84% Stay, 16% Go
- Kyle Schwarber — 82% Stay, 18% Go
- Brandon Marsh — 73% Stay, 27% Go
- Ranger Suárez — 69% Stay, 31% Go
- Orion Kerkering — 66% Stay, 34% Go
- Alec Bohm — 59% Stay, 41% Go
- Taijuan Walker — 31% Stay, 69% Go
- Max Kepler — 27% Stay, 73% Go
- Nick Castellanos — 17% Stay, 83% Go