The Virtual Terrace • Re: Who will make the Super League play offs ?
AS108 wrote:
At least 3 of them suggestions are ridiculous. Manfredi’s been injured for about 2 years so that’s a joke, Johnstone is the most overrated player in SL, he’s defensively awful and that good that Wakefield dropped him. As for Burgess he’s hardly great, was decent before he went to Australia, you’ve said Charnley because you’re a Wire fan and he scored a few tries against League 1 Bradford. McGillvary and Hall are the only acceptable ones and even then McGillvarys been injured and rubbish when he’s played so far this season, we’ve seen the best of him. Hall is still good but Makinson is more athletic and personally I prefer him. Apart from Hall and McGillvary, that lists a joke. As for Wire winning nothing you’ve got no chance, we were poor and still thumped you 30-12 at HJ, won’t win anything until you have a decent half back partnership, Brown and Roberts are garbage.
Put Johnstone in that Saints team and he would do as well if not better than Makinson imo. Playing for a top side means makinson defence isn’t tested anywhere near as much as Johnstones is playing for Wakey
Statistics: Posted by Tricky2309 — Tue May 01, 2018 9:47 pm