Separate threads vs P/I/P

The standard protocol in this forum has been to run three threads per regular game: a pregame thread, an in-game thread, and a postgame.

The upside is that threads tend to stay a reasonable length. The downside is that it can be confusing or duplicative (which thread did I post that in?)

So there's a suggestion that going forward we combine all three threads into a single, as we do with non-MLS games.

Thoughts?