Today's Game Hall of Fame Committee Ballot
The National Baseball Hall of Fame announced the candidates on the Today's Game Committee. The Today's Game Committee considers players who's primary contributions occurred from 1988 or later. Unfortunately this year's slate of candidates doesn't seem particularly interesting, at first blush. This year's ballot shapes up as follows (with some initial commentary from me):
Harold Baines, RF (JAWS 74th)
Harold Baines gets plenty of discussion because of his neat batting line (.289/.356/.465), and high hit count (2,866). However, he did not receive a ton of consideration from the BBWAA, topping out at 6.1% of the vote. This is the second time he's been considered by the Today's Game Committeee; the first time was two years ago and he received less than five votes (12 are needed for induction).
Albert Belle, LF (38th JAWS)
Like Baines, this is Belle's second rodeo on the Today's Game Committee. Belle performed as well as Baines on the BBWAA ballot (7.7% of the vote once). Unlike Baines, I do think Belle posted some excellent Hall of Fame seasons, and was probably robbed of an MVP award at some point. Like Baines: Belle received less than five votes two years ago.
Joe Carter, RF (101st)
Carter is an interesting addition to the ballot this year; he's never appeared on a Veteran's Committee before. He's a one-and-done BBWAA candidate (3.8%). Carter is best known for hitting the walkoff home run to end the 1993 World Series for the Toronto Blue Jays.
Will Clark, 1B (26th)
Like Belle & Baines, Will Clark was a candidate two years ago. Like Belle & Baines: he received less than five votes (overall seven of the candidates from the 2016 ballot return, all of them received less than five votes). Clark only appeared once on the BBWAA ballot (I hope everyone else is sensing a theme here). Clark, unlike the other candidates, has a case for the Hall of Fame, and has largely been ignored by the relevant committees and the BBWAA.
Orel Hershiser, SP (83rd)
Orel has the highest BBWAA vote tally of the bunch at 11.2%, but also dropped off his second ballot. He also received less than five votes two years ago. Orel is famous in Cleveland for his post season heroics as part of two AL Pennant winning clubs. He spent most of his career in Los Angeles, and played best for them.
Davey Johnson, Manager, 1,372 Wins, 1 World Series
Johnson is a fairly accomplished manager. He led the 1986 Mets to a World Series trophy. Otherwise he is less distinguished. He's also managed the national United States team, and most recently managed the Washington Nationals (in what seems a never ending carousel of managers out of that weird club).
Charlie Manuel, Manager, 1,000 Wins, 1 World Series
An interesting choice for this ballot, and his first appearance. Maneul is best known for managing the excellent Phillies teams in the late 2000s and early 2010s. He brought home two pennants, and a World Series for Philadelphia. Manuel also managed the Indians, and is a mentor to Hall of Famer Jim Thome.
Lou Piniella, Manager, 1,835 Wins, 1 World Series
Finishing off our managers is Lou Piniella. Another candidate from two years ago who, but Piniella garnered seven votes. Piniella is probably the most accomplished manager of the three listed here, and managed the most teams. He was unceremoniously kicked out of Chicago in 2010, and has not managed since.
Lee Smith, Closer, (JAWS 16th)
Fresh off the BBWAA ballot, Smith is the most accomplished player on this ballot (Hall of Fame wise). Smith topped out over 50% of the vote on the BBWAA ballot, and aged off after 15 years. This is a good sign for eventual induction, as every player who has received 50% of the BBWAA vote has eventually been inducted, besides Gil Hodges. Smith suffered from a stuffed ballot at the end of his tenure, and is famous for holding the saves record until Trevor Hoffman (and eventually Mariano Rivera) smashed it.
George Steinbrenner, Owner
Steinbrenner competently owned the Yankees for several decades before dying. He is known for feuding with managers, and signing outrageous free agent contracts. I don't have much to say here, I'm not even sure owners should enter the Hall of Fame.
Outlook
Overall this year's committee is pretty boring. Seven re-runs, and none of them particularly interesting candidates. Taking them by category:
Managers:
None of the managers are particularly interesting, and when compared with their contemporaries already inducted: Bobby Cox, Joe Torre, and Tony La Russa; none stand out. One World Series isn't really enough to enter the Hall of Fame, outside some type of major accomplishment. Of the three, I think Lou Piniella is the best manager (and the most likely to earn induction). He might get some traction, although the ballot two years ago only produced two inductees (Bud Selig and John Schuerholz), so it's unlikely the voters lacked room on their ballots to fill in for Lou. Piniella ranks 14th all time in wins, which is pretty good for a modern manager. The 1990 Reds featured several Hall of Fame players, which might help.
Players:
The list of players is pretty disappointing. Part of the problem is many of these players have actually been inducted already, or they are stained by steroids. The most interesting eligible candidate, in my opinion, is probably Mark McGwire. McGwire, obviously, admitted he used steroids. Otherwise this list is largely one or re-treads. Harold Baines, Albert Belle & Joe Carter simply are not Hall of Fame caliber players, and really aren't worth discussing anymore, and the very least the Hall could have done is to include some other players eligible for this list who we haven't seen before like Chuck Knoblauch & David Justice.
This leads me to the somewhat interesting players on this list: Orel Hershiser & Will Clark. Of the two we've probably heard the most about Orel Hershiser. Hershiser won a Cy Young Award in 1988, and was the 1988 World Series MVP. He pitched 3,000 innings with an ERA+ of 112, and thus has a viable Hall of Fame case. His career matches up with some Hall of Fame players, including Jack Morris.* Will Clark's case is a bit less pronounced, but he did have a crazy season in 1989, and is probably about as good as Tony Perez, and Orlando Cepeda, so he too has a Hall of Fame case. I don't think either of them are close to the best at their position outside the Hall of Fame, or even outside the Hall and eligible, but they do have cases.
*This is of course the problem with Jack Morris. Hershiser was a much better pitcher than Morris, and was also good in the post season (career 2.59 ERA in 132 innings, including four complete games and two shut outs). There really isn't a case for Morris, but not Hershiser, outside of pitchers wins.
The most interesting case (to watch at least) is easily Lee Smith. Smith topped out at the BBWAA level at 50.6% of the vote, and thus can easily claim to be the most qualified player on the ballot. On a fairly weak ballot, I wouldn't be surprised if they vote him into the Hall of Fame fairly easily. Most candidates who wind up on the Veteran's Committee with 50+ percent of the vote get inducted.
George Steinbrenner
I don't know what to do with him. I don't think he'll go anywhere, and kind of wastes away on this ballot.
Conclusion
This wont be a particularly interesting year for the Veteran's Committee. Next year will be interesting to watch as both the Golden Years and Early Days Committees meet, and the Golden Years contain a whole slew of overlooked players who could finally gain induction. Outside of Wes Ferrell there isn't anyone I particularly want to see inducted into the Hall of Fame from the Segregation Era...I mean Early Days Committee.

